1. Home
  2. /
  3. Sweets
  4. /
  5. Pies
  6. /
  7. The Best Pie Flavors...

The Best Pie Flavors & Where to Try Them

THE MOST POPULAR PIE FLAVORS YOU MUST TRY

Piedaho Hand-decorated Pies
Piedaho’s Hand-Decorated Pies

Any way you slice it, the humble pie is a delicious treat. Whether sweet or savory, pies are a big part of holidays, celebrations, and desserts. Pies can also be the main meal. There is even a day devoted to it: Pi Day.

What Are The Most Popular Pie Flavors?

Here are hundreds of pie flavors — at Goldbelly we have 350-plus pie flavors. Some of the most popular pie flavors are:

Pies should not be confused with tarts or whoopie pies. Tarts are similar to pies except they do not have a top crust. The bottom crusts are thicker than regular pie. Whoopie pies are a cake-cookie sandwich with a cream center.

Key Lime Pie

This citrus pie is synonymous with Florida. It has a tart custard filling made with Key lime juice. The filling is nestled on a graham cracker crust and topped with whipped cream. Some credit fishermen in the Florida Keys with inventing the Key lime pie. Others say the Borden Dairy company invented it. Either way you slice it, Key lime pie is sublime!

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Pie

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe Key Lime Pie

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe makes its 9 inch Key lime pie with Key lime juice made in house. Each pie has a graham cracker crust and is topped with luscious whipped cream.

Key West Key Lime Pie Co. Famous Key Lime Pie

Key West Key Lime Pie Co. Famous Key Lime Pie

Key West Key Lime Pie Co.’s  Famous Key Lime Pie is made with a 100-years-old recipe. Each pie is made by hand with all-natural ingredients like fresh Key limes sourced in Key West, Florida.

Apple Pie

Apple pie is arguably one of the most popular pie flavors. A symbol of America, the apple pie was actually invented by the British. Apple pie is simply made with sliced apples on double-crusted pastry dough.

The Elegant Farmer’s Original Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag

The Elegant Farmer Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag

The Elegant Farmer bakes more than 250,000 of its award-winning Apple Pie Baked in a Paper Bag®. This unique pie is stuffed with mounds of Ida Red apples. It is baked in a paper bag, which makes the top crust crunchy.

William Greenberg Desserts Apple Pie

William Greenberg Desserts Apple Pie

New York City’s William Greenberg Desserts stuffed its delicious Apple Pie with the freshest, juiciest apples. Each pie is topped with a flaky lattice crust covered in luscious crumbs.

Pecan Pie

Pecan pie made with toasted pecans, is pure perfection. Some believe the French who settled in New Orleans invented the pecan pie, but it was a Texas who created it. The first recipe for pecan pie appeared in an American cookbook in 1898. Pecan pies include classic Southern pecan pie, chocolate pecan pie, and whiskey pecan pie.

Pecan Pie

Commander’s Palace Pecan Pie

Famous for its Creole cuisine, Commander’s Palace also makes an amazing Pecan Pie. This pecan pie includes a sticky filling of pecans, sugar, and vanilla nestled on a perfect crust.

Goode Co. Barbeque Famous Pecan Pie

Goode Co. Barbeque Famous Pecan Pie

Presented in a wooden box, Goode Co. Barbeque’s Famous Pecan Pie is a hefty 5 lb. pie filled with Texas pecans harvested from the Brazos River. The Brazos Bottom Pecan Pie is gooey, rich, and extraordinary.

Pumpkin Pie

Enjoyed for centuries, pumpkin pie was first served in New England, particularly during Thanksgiving. A version that resembles a pumpkin pie with crust appeared in an 18th century cookbook. Pumpkin pie is made with a crimped pie crust filled with fresh pumpkin and spices. Fresh pumpkin and pie crust.

Sweetie Pies Bakery Pumpkin Pie

Sweetie Pies Bakery Pumpkin Pie

Sweetie Pies Bakery makes classic American pies like Pumpkin Pie. Each pie’s creamy filling is made with pumpkin purée, brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and allspice. Each pie is topped with a handful of flaky pastry “leaves.”

Wick's Pies Pumpkin Spice Pie

Wick’s Pies Pumpkin Spice Pie

Wick’s Pies uses family recipes to make its classic pies, including Pumpkin Spice Pie. Each 9 inch pie includes cinnamon, clove, coriander, ginger, and nutmeg.

Cherry Pie

Fruit pies were first created in the 1500s. Queen Elizabeth I is credited with creating the first Cherry Pie. Cherry pies are bright red pies filled with dozens of fresh cherries. They are topped with lattice pie crust tops.

Grand Traverse Pie Company Cherry Crumb Pie

Grand Traverse Pie Company Cherry Crumb Pie

Each tart and sweet Cherry Crumb Pie is mmmemorable. Grand Traverse Pie Company’s Cherry Crumb Pie has Northern Michigan Montmorency cherries, crumb topping, and a berry juice ring around the crust.

Wick's Pies Cherry Pie

Wick’s Pies Cherry Pie

Winchester, Indiana’s Wick’s Pies makes some of the best classic Cherry Pie. Each 9 inch pie is 2 lbs. and made with tart cherries, sugar, and cinnamon.

Coconut Cream Pie

Get a taste of the tropics with Coconut Cream Pie. This light and creamy pie is filled with coconut custard, cream, and coconut shavings.

Achatz Handmade Pie Co. Coconut Cream Pie

Achatz Handmade Pie Co. Coconut Cream Pie

Since 1993, Achatz Handmade Pie Co. has been making pies like their Coconut Cream Pie. Their Coconut Cream Pie is made of coconut pastry cream, whipped topping, and toasted coconut.

Betty's Pies Coconut Cream Pie

Betty’s Pies Coconut Cream Pie

Betty’s Pies in Two Harbors, Minnesota, is famous for its cream pies. Their Coconut Cream Pie is a nostalgic mis of  fluffy coconut custard cream, whipped cream, and toasted coconut.

Boston Cream Pie

The Omni Parker House Hotel in Boston invented the Boston Cream Pie in 1856. Despite its name, Boston Cream Pie is technically a cake. This treat has two layers of sponge cake and pastry cream topped with chocolate ganache. Boston Cream Pie is the official state dessert of Massachusetts.

Omni Parker House Hotel Boston Cream Pie

Omni Parker House Hotel The Original Boston Cream Pie

More than 160 years later, Augustine Anezin’s original Boston Cream Pie is still served at Omni Parker House Hotel. Each pie is handmade with layers of golden cake and pastry cream and topped with chocolate.

Flour Bakery + Cafe Boston Cream Pie

Flour Bakery + Cafe Boston Cream Pie

Boston’s Flour Bakery + Cafe makes its version of Boston Cream Pie with yellow cake and vanilla cream. Their chocolate ganache has a hint of coffee flavor and is served on the side. Before eating, heat the ganache and pour it all over this beautiful treat.

Berry Pies

Berry Pies are berry, berry good. These double crust pies come brimming with fruit like:

  • Blackberry
  • Blueberry
  • Mixed Berry
  • Raspberry
  • Strawberry
  • Strawberry rhubarb
Bread and Roses Bakery Maine Blueberry Pie

Bread and Roses Bakery Maine Blueberry Pie

Ogunquit, Maine’s Bread and Roses Bakery makes its Blueberry Pie the old fashioned way with Maine blueberries. Each pie is made in small batches. The blueberry filling is stirred by hand over the stove just like your mom or grandmother used to do. 

Cootie Brown's Strawberry Pie

Cootie Brown’s Strawberry Pie

Cootie Brown’s Strawberry Pie features a strawberry cake-like crust filled with layers of sweet cream cheese and ripe strawberries. Each pie arrives in a reusable pie tin.

Read More: Must Try Pies For Thanksgiving

Crust us. Our fruit, cream, nut, and outrageous pies in 350+ flavors are some of the best you have ever had.