The Best Halloween Desserts on Goldbelly 2022


Jack O'Lantern Cake
Duff Goldman’s Halloween Jack-O-Lantern Cake

Here comes Halloween! It’s the spookiest time of year, when ghosts, ghouls, gravestones, cobwebs, and pumpkins become lawn decorations and children transform into their favorite Disney characters for a day. But we all know what Halloween is REALLY about: the FOOD! 

There’s nothing quite like the feeling of coming home after trick or treating with a pillowcase full of Halloween candy, but who needs another plain ol’ “fun size” candy bar when you can indulge in Goldbelly’s jaw-dropping collection of Halloween-themed cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and more!

No matter if you’re hosting a huge party, a Día de los Muertos celebration, or just looking for some Halloween treats, treat yourself to the best Halloween desserts shipping nationwide! If you’re looking to take your festivities to the next level this year, these desserts are undeniably BOO-licious!

Halloween Cookies

Iced Halloween Sugar Cookies

Iced Halloween Sugar Cookies By Elegant Desserts

You can spend all day whipping up a variety of treats, or you can order this impressive array from Elegant Desserts! These buttery cookies are handmade with plenty of detail, and are all dressed up as pumpkins and bats.

Halloween Cookie Decorating Kit

Halloween Cookie Decorating Kit By The Goddess & Grocer

This might just be the perfect Halloween DIY project for kids! Get creative and top these cookies with icing and sprinkles, then eat your edible works of art!

Halloween Candy Shortbread 

Halloween Candy Shortbread By Shortbread Society

We can safely say you’ve never seen shortbread cookies like these! Take your pick from a variety of decadent Halloween-themed shortbread, including one that’s candy corn-inspired and another that’s loaded with Reese’s Pieces. They’re seriously gourmet and drop dead gorgeous! 

Pumpkin Conchas By El Bolillo Bakery

Conchas are a traditional Mexican sweet bread, and the legendary Houston panadería El Bolillo Bakery is giving them a decidedly Halloweeny makeover by turning them into pumpkins! These are flavored with cinnamon and topped with an orange cookie crunch, and they’re perfect when warmed and enjoyed with a cup of hot chocolate!

Halloween Cupcakes

Giant Peanut Butter Cups

GIANT Pumpkin Patch Peanut Butter Cups By 4am Candy Co.

What happens when you take a classic peanut butter cup and top it with a pile of the most popular candies and MORE chocolate? A ridiculously decadent Halloween mashup, is what!

Vegan Gluten Free Halloween Cupcakes

Vegan + Gluten Free Halloween Cupcakes By Erin McKenna’s Bakery

Vegan? Gluten-free? Not to worry! One of the most magical things about cupcakes is that they can be adapted for just about any dietary restriction (or holiday) you can think of. These cupcakes aren’t just beautifully decorated, they’re also completely vegan and gluten free!)

Halloween Cakes

Jack O'Lantern Cake

Chocolate Caramel Jack-O-Lantern Cake By Duff Goldman

A classic jack-o’-lantern cake is guaranteed to be a showstopping party centerpiece! This picture-perfect cake from the Ace of Cakes himself, Duff Goldman, is a chocolate cake layered with caramel cream cheese and decorated with orange frosting, a black fondant jack-o-lantern face, a green buttercream stem, and sprinkles!

Spooky Red Velvet Cake

Spooky Red Velvet Cake By Daisy Cakes

When does a classic red velvet cake become downright spooky? When oozing red ganache turns any Halloween party into a bloody good time! Be sure to serve with a knife stabbed into it for maximum effect.

Day of the Dead Chocolate Layer Cake

Day of the Dead Chocolate Layer Cake By O&H Danish Bakery

Don’t forget that November 2nd is the Mexican Day of the Dead, a time to honor the dead with ofrendas (altars), parades, and music. This cake is made with layers of red velvet and chocolate cake with chocolate frosting, and it’s topped with a traditional Día de los Muertos-styled skull.

Boozy Eyeball Jelly Cake

The Boozy Eyeball Jelly Cake By Solid Wiggles

You can resort to old-school Jell-O shots at your (grown-up) party… or you can get a load of this! Your guests will be wide-eyed when they catch a glimpse of this creepy, boozy “cake” made with ingredients including orange juice, rum, Angostura bitters, and sweet coconut milk. 

More Halloween Treats

Halloween Oreo Brownies & Cookies

Halloween Oreo Brownies & Cookies By Baked in Color

Orange brownies and cookies are a no-brainer, and these swirled brownies are loaded with Oreo cookies! The accompanying orange & black cookies are soft, gooey, and loaded with chocolate chips. 

Halloween Message Donuts

Halloween Message Donuts By Angel Food Bakery

Say it with doughnuts! Lay out a centerpiece of freshly fried yeast-raised donuts, creatively frosted with Halloween-themed decorations and spelling out either LET’S GET SPOOKY or HAPPY HALLOWEEN. These just might be too pretty to eat! (Might be!)

Halloween Rice Krispie Treats

Halloween Rice Krispie Treats By Treat House

Take a bite out of Halloween with Treat House’s Halloween Rice Krispie treats. From purple bats to mini Frankenstein heads to mummies, each tiny treat features a mini design that is big on taste and spirit. 

And here’s some really good news: this is just the tip of the sweet & spooky iceberg! There’s plenty more Halloween inspiration where these came from, and you can find the full collection here! Happy Halloween!