THE BEST BATCHES OF HOLIDAY COOKIES FROM AMERICA’S BEST BAKERS
It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas…in our kitchens and homes thanks to super cute Christmas cookies. These shapely sugar cookies in a kaleidoscope of colors are far from cookie cutter. These chewy, crunchy cookies are dressed in dragées, sprinkles, and frosting to impress this holiday season.
What is the Most Eaten Cookie at Christmas?
Sugar cookies are the most eaten cookie at Christmas. The most popular Christmas cookie flavors are typically based on where you live and your personal preferences.
Popular Christmas cookies include:
- Candy Cane Cookies
- Chocolate Crinkle Christmas Cookies
- Gingerbread Cookies
- Italian Cookies
- Oatmeal Cookies
- Peanut Butter Blossoms
- Russian Tea Cakes
- Sugar Cookies
Read More: Christmas Desserts to Try in 2023
Christmas Cookies Gifts & Mail Order Cookies for You & Yours
Show how much you care with freshly baked cookies. These Xmas cookies and your thoughtfulness are a perfect batch. We betcha can’t eat just one!
Elle’s Belles Bakery’s Snowman & Snowflake Christmas Sugar Cookies
Elle’s Belles Balery’s Snowman & Snowflake Christmas Sugar Cookies are a sweet way to express love. It’s literally iced onto each snowman. For two decades, this Bozeman, Montana bakery has been baking hand-frosted cookies.
This cute cookie pack serves 6 and includes 3 snowman and 3 snowflake cookies. These make perfect stocking stuffers as the cookies are wrapped in polka dot cellophane tied with a red grosgrain ribbon.
Shortbread Society’s Holiday Shortbread
Hey shorty, get ready to celebrate the ho-ho-holidays with Shortbread Society’s Holiday Shortbread. Each custom-made tray of regular and gluten-free shortbread is filled with Christmas cookie cheer. Chef “Scottish Francis” Legge (who starred on season 5 of “Masterchef”) and his wife Christine add modern touches to classic Scottish shortbread.
Get wrapped up in flavors like Sugar Cookie with sweet dough buttercream and holiday sparkle and Cherry Bakewell with Maraschino cherries and raspberry and almond pie filling. Each is ready to gift in a limited edition gift box with tissue paper, ribbon, sticker, and handwritten card.
The Cookie Joint’s Christmas Cookie Fries Gift Basket
Enjoy some fries along with the shaking of Christmas packages under the tree. Jill Balick and Susie Schuster’s whimsical cookie fries are a creative crinkle cut cookie perfect for snacking and sharing with family and friends.
The Cookie Joint’s Christmas Cookies Fries Gift Basket comes with 8 cartons of Cookie Fries in flavors like Shortbread, Green Mint Chocolate Chip, and Cinnamon Spice. This gift basket includes 8 dipping sauces like hazelnut, marshmallow, and salted caramel.
Big Fat Cookie’s Twelve Days of Christmas Cookies
What better way to celebrate the 12 days of Christmas than with cookies? Go big or bah humbug with Big Fat Cookie’s Twelve Days of Christmas Cookies. Each 6-oz. cookie is colossal cookie goodness shipped straight from Chicago.
Indulge in ooey gooey greatness like:
- Brown Butter Christmas Cookie: Brown butter cookie topped with festive Christmas sprinkles
- Red Velvet Nutella Dream Cookie: Red velvet cookie studded with semi-sweet and white chocolate chips, filled with Nutella, and topped with a handmade Christmas Sprinkle Big Oreo
- Triple Chocolate Peppermint Cookie: Triple chocolate cookie filled with fudge and filled with and topped with house-made pink peppermint
Collegetown Bagels’ Ice Assorted Christmas Cookies
Cue the cuteness: countdown to Christmas with Collegetown Bagels’ cut-out Christmas cookies. The family-run Ithaca, New York, bagel shop bakes nostalgia and fun with its Ice Assorted Christmas Cookies. Each cookie is hand decorated by CTB’s pastry chef.
Carlo’s Bakery’s Butter Cookie Box
Get everyone’s favorite cookies this Christmas by ordering from Hoboken, New Jersey’s “Cake Boss” Buddy Valastro. Carlo’s Bakery’s Butter Cookie Box includes two dozen-plus Italian classics like:
- Apricot cookies
- Nutella cookies
- Sprinkle cookies
Elegant Desserts’ Iced Sugar Cookie Christmas Gift Set
Deck your dessert buffet with these joyful cookies from Brooklyn kosher dessert company Elegant Desserts. Celebrate with Elegant Desserts’ Iced Sugar Cookie Christmas Gift Set.
This kosher Christmas cookie gift set features one dozen handcrafted butter cookies in festive designs like candy canes, Christmas trees, and stockings. It’s shipped and served on a lucite tray.
Zola Bakes’ Christmas Rainbow Cookies
Make the holidays merry and bright — and colorful! — with Samantha Zola’s Italian rainbow cookies. Zola Bakes’ bite-size rainbows are just what you’re wishing for this season.
Zola Bakes’ Christmas Rainbow Cookies includes 20 almond cake cookies. Half are layered with raspberry jam and half are layered with chocolate hazelnut spread. Each cookie is topped with dark and white chocolate drip and Christmas sprinkles.
Baked in the Burg’s Christmas Deep Dish Cookie Sampler
Impress Santa with a plateful of Baked in the Burg’s deep dish cookies. Each 4-inch cookie weighs about 5 ounces. and is packed like Santa’s sleigh.
Sleigh cookie cravings with this St. Petersburg, Florida, bakery’s Christmas Deep Dish Cookie Sampler. This pack includes the following festive flavors:
- Chocolate Chip Sea Salt
- Double Chocolate Peppermint
- Oatmeal Raisin
Red Velvet NYC’s Sugar Cookie Tree DIY Baking Kit
Gather your family and friends for a bake-a-thon and festive fun. This Brooklyn bakery’s cookie kit is perfect for those who dream of Pinterest perfect cookies without much fuss.
Each Sugar Cookie Tree DIY Baking Kit includes everything to bake 32 star-shaped cookies and turn them into a cookie tree. The end result is a social media post-worthy Christmas tree made from stacked star-shaped sugar cookies and delicious memories.