1. Home
  2. /
  3. Sweets
  4. /
  5. Cookies
  6. /
  7. The Best Christmas Cookies...

The Best Christmas Cookies Shipped to Your Door

THE BEST BATCHES OF HOLIDAY COOKIES FROM AMERICA’S BEST BAKERS

Best Christmas Cookies Goldbelly

The most popular Christmas cookies in America are decorated sugar cookies and gingerbread, followed by classics like snickerdoodles, Linzer cookies, butter cookies, shortbread, Italian rainbow cookies, chocolate crinkles, and snowball cookies. Many come from European baking traditions that immigrants brought to the U.S., and families bake them by the dozen for cookie swaps, holiday parties, gifts, and plates left out for Santa.

Classic Christmas cookies at a glance

  • Sugar cookies: cut into trees, stars, and stockings and decorated with icing and sprinkles
  • Gingerbread: spiced with ginger, cinnamon, cloves, and molasses, often shaped into people or houses
  • Snickerdoodles: soft cookies rolled in cinnamon sugar
  • Linzer cookies: buttery sandwich cookies with a jam-filled window, from Austria
  • Butter cookies: delicate piped or pressed cookies, a Danish and Italian bakery classic
  • Shortbread: a rich Scottish cookie made from butter, sugar, and flour
  • Rainbow cookies: Italian-American almond cake layers with jam and chocolate
  • Chocolate crinkles: fudgy cookies rolled in powdered sugar that crack as they bake
  • Snowball cookies: nutty butter cookies coated in powdered sugar, also called Russian tea cakes or Mexican wedding cookies

What are the most popular Christmas cookies?

Sugar cookies

Decorated sugar cookies are one of the most popular Christmas cookies in America. The simple vanilla dough is rolled, cut into holiday shapes like trees, stars, and snowmen, and decorated with royal icing, frosting, and sprinkles.

Gingerbread cookies

Gingerbread has been a Christmas tradition in Europe for centuries, especially in Germany. Gingerbread cookies are spiced with ginger, cinnamon, and cloves and sweetened with molasses. Gingerbread people are the most famous shape, and gingerbread houses are a favorite holiday project.

Snickerdoodles

Snickerdoodles are soft, chewy butter cookies rolled in cinnamon sugar before baking. They likely came to America with Dutch and German immigrants, and recipes began appearing in American newspapers in the late 1800s.

Linzer cookies

Linzer cookies come from Linz, Austria, where they’re based on the Linzer torte. They’re buttery sandwich cookies, often made with ground nuts, filled with raspberry jam, and topped with a cookie that has a cutout “window,” usually dusted with powdered sugar.

Butter cookies and shortbread

Butter cookies are delicate, crisp cookies piped or pressed into shapes and often topped with sprinkles, jam, or chocolate. They’re a staple of Italian-American bakery cookie trays and Danish cookie tins. Shortbread, from Scotland, is denser and richer, made from just butter, sugar, and flour.

Read more: Shortbread vs. Sugar Cookies vs. Butter Cookies

Italian rainbow cookies

Rainbow cookies, also called tricolor or seven-layer cookies, are an Italian-American bakery classic. They stack three layers of almond cake, colored red, white, and green like the Italian flag, with jam between the layers and chocolate on top.

Chocolate crinkles and snowball cookies

Chocolate crinkles are fudgy cookies rolled in powdered sugar, which cracks into a “crinkled” pattern as they bake. Snowball cookies are small, round butter cookies made with ground pecans or walnuts and rolled in powdered sugar. They go by many names, including Russian tea cakes and Mexican wedding cookies.

What is the Most Eaten Cookie at Christmas?

Sugar cookies are the most eaten and most widely recognized Christmas cookie. Their simple vanilla flavor, soft texture, and customizable shapes and decorations make them a holiday staple in homes across the U.S. While sugar cookies lead the list, other popular Christmas cookies include chocolate crinkles, gingerbread cookies, Italian bakery cookies, peanut butter blossoms, Russian tea cakes, and oatmeal-based varieties. Regional traditions and family recipes often influence which cookies appear on the Christmas dessert table, but sugar cookies remain the clear nationwide favorite.

Where can you order the best Christmas cookies?

Goldbelly ships Christmas cookies nationwide from bakeries across the country.

Be a smart cookie this Christmas. Get on the nice list by shipping Christmas cookies and Christmas desserts nationwide on Goldbelly!

Goldbelly E Gift