1. Home
  2. /
  3. Holidays
  4. /
  5. Top Thanksgiving Desserts That...

Top Thanksgiving Desserts That Everyone Will Gobble Up

PUMPKIN PIE IS JUST THE BEGINNING

The Piecaken
PieCaken Bakeshop’s Original PieCaken

Out of all the major holidays, Thanksgiving is the one that revolves around food the most. After all, what better way is there to celebrate what we’re thankful for than by gathering around a table with friends and family and digging into a huge feast? 

The main part of the Thanksgiving meal is all well and good (depending on whether you love turkey or not), but for us, Thanksgiving dinner isn’t Thanksgiving dinner without Thanksgiving dessert!

What Desserts Do You Eat on Thanksgiving?

We all know the classic Thanksgiving desserts – pumpkin pie, apple pie, maybe sweet potato pie in the South. If we’re lucky they come from a local bakery, but more often than not they’re afterthoughts picked up front he supermarket along with the boxed stuffing mix and canned cranberry sauce. And that’s a shame! 

America’s best autumn pies, cakes, and more desserts are shipping straight to your door in time for Thanksgiving. These come straight from some of the most beloved bakeries and pastry chefs in America, and they’re going to knock your guests’ socks off!

Read More: Must-Try Pies for Thanksgiving

Top Thanksgiving Desserts

The PieCaken Shop’s PieCaken

The PieCaken Shop’s PieCaken

It’s the Thanksgiving dessert to end all Thanksgiving desserts! From famed pastry chef Zac Young, The PieCaken is four desserts in one, all stacked together: pecan pie on the bottom, pumpkin pie in the middle, and spice cake on top, all layered together with cinnamon buttercream and topped with apple pie filling!

Read More: What is PieCaken and Where to Buy it?

Michele’s Pies’ Maple Pumpkin Pie With Pecan Streusel

Every pie at Michele’s Pies is made by hand at Michele Stuart’s eponymous gourmet pie shop in Norwalk, Connecticut. To make their famous Maple Pumpkin Pie With Pecan Streusel, they purée fresh pumpkin and add Vermont maple syrup and cream to give the filling a rich and creamy texture. It’s then poured into a flaky old-fashioned pie crust and topped with a generous layer of pecans dusted with brown sugar and cinnamon.

Read More: Best Pumpkin Pies That Ship Nationwide

Maple Pumpkin Pie with Pumpkin Streusel
The Village Bakery’s Mountain Apple Stack Cake

The Village Bakery’s Mountain Apple Stack Cake

Apple Stack Cakes were originally used as wedding cakes in the Appalachian Mountains. Each invited family would bake a layer of the cake, adding it to the base as they arrived on the day of the wedding with the bride’s family providing the filling. Using an old family recipe, the Village Bakery uses 100% Tennessee green apples from orchards located only a few miles from the Smoky Mountains to make their classic Apple Stack Cake. They hand peel, slice, and cook the apples, spicing them with traditional Appalachian spices before spreading them between the numerous layers of moist cake.

East Side Cheesecake’s” The Apple of My Third Eye” Apple Pie Cheesecake

This is the perfect Thanksgiving cheesecake! A cinnamon sugar graham cracker base is topped with a creamy cheesecake center made with handmade buttermilk cream cheese, topped off with tart brown sugar apple pie filling, and finished with a crunchy oat crisp. It comes with a bottle of homemade bourbon Tipsy Caramel Sauce for you to drizzle all over the top!

East Side Cheesecake’s The Apple of My Third Eye Apple Pie Cheesecake
We Take the Cake’s Pumpkin Maple Cinnamon Bundt Cake

We Take the Cake’s Pumpkin Maple Cinnamon Bundt Cake

This Pumpkin Maple Bundt Cake features the seasonal flavors of earthly pumpkin puree, allspice, and warm cinnamon. Adorn it with the included maple cinnamon cream cheese frosting to perfect this delicious and satisfying dessert.

Splash Cafe’s Chocolate Thanksgiving Cake

The low-key Splash Cafe first opened its doors just steps from the Pismo Beach Pier in 1989, and since 1991 it’s been run by Joanne Currie and her husband Ross, who turned it into a certified local landmark. This Chocolate Thanksgiving Cake is specially decorated for Thanksgiving, and topped with mini pumpkin pie slices!

Read More: Best Fall Cakes & Desserts

Splash Cafe’s Chocolate Thanksgiving Cake
Ina Garten’s Barefoot Contessa’s Carrot Cake

Ina Garten’s Barefoot Contessa’s Carrot Cake

From none other than Ina Garten herself, this six-inch carrot cake is made with plenty of freshly-grated carrots and a hint of cinnamon, and it’s studded with raisins and walnuts. The creamy frosting is enriched by Italian mascarpone and cream cheese, and it’s topped off with a touch of candied ginger!

Duff Goldman’s Pumpkin Spice Cake

From Food Network star and “Ace of Cakes” Duff Goldman, this beautiful four-layer Pumpkin Spice Cake has vanilla cream cheese filling and frosting, and it’s decorated with frosting pumpkins on the top and a pumpkin crumb layer on the side!

Duff Goldman’s Pumpkin Spice Cake
JARS By Dani’s Thanksgiving Mini Cake Jars

JARS By Dani’s Thanksgiving Mini Cake Jars

This Thanksgiving, every guest can get their very own mini cake jar! Flavors include Chocolate Pumpkin Cheesecake, Cookie Dough, Fudge Brownie, Brown Butter Pumpkin, and Cinnamon Spice Cake, and they’re all decked out for the holiday.

Blue Owl Bakery’s Levee High Caramel Pecan Apple Pie

This might just be the most stunning apple pie of all time! Founded in the historic town of Kimmswick, Missouri, by Mary Hostetter in 1983, Blue Owl Bakery is most famous for this Levee High Apple Pie, made with 18 Golden Delicious apples piled high in a made-from-scratch crust. Bake the pie at home, and cover it with caramel sauce loaded with pecans!

Blue Owl Bakery’s Levee High Caramel Pecan Apple Pie
The Nuns Of New Skete’s Pumpkin Cheesecake

The Nuns Of New Skete’s Pumpkin Cheesecake

This small monastery in upstate New York is producing what many believe to be the finest cheesecakes in the country, all made by hand by the sisters. If you like pumpkin, you will love this Pumpkin Cheesecake, baked in ginger and pumpkin-spiced crumbs.

There’s no shortage of amazing Thanksgiving desserts out there, and they’re all shipping nationwide with Goldbelly! Check out the full Thanksgiving Desserts collection, and discover all great Thanksgiving foods.